The 2 Most Overlooked Tactics in Your Email Marketing Strategy

When we talk about the strategy behind the resend, we’re delving into a realm where timing, content, and audience insight converge to elevate your campaign’s effectiveness.

The Email Marketing Strategy You’re Overlooking: Resends

So, you’ve crafted the perfect email campaign, hit ‘send’, and then waited for the magic to happen. But instead of seeing those open rates skyrocket, you’re left wondering why half your audience seems to be playing hard to get. Sound familiar?

Let me share a little secret with you: the magic lies in the resend. Yep, that’s right—the humble art of sending your marketing emails out for a second spin. Why? Because life’s busy, inboxes are overflowing, and sometimes your first email gets lost in the shuffle.

Case in Point: Our Email Adventure

Let’s dive into a real-world scenario. Our own email marketing…

We sent out a marketing email post-bank holiday, choosing an off-peak time to dodge the inbox avalanche. The result? A 45.6% open rate and a 2.3% click-through rate. Not too shabby, especially since it soared above industry averages.

Email Marketing Strategy

But here’s the kicker: that still left us with a whopping 54.4% of our audience who didn’t open the email. What’s a marketer to do? Give up? Never! We hit them with a strategic resend, tweaking three crucial elements:

  • Time of Day
  • Day of the Week
  • Subject Line

The Strategy Behind the Resend

In our example, last time we chose a Tuesday morning; this time, we went for Thursday, pre-business hours, to catch early birds and commuters. And voila, a fresh batch of opens and clicks, pushing our overall rates up significantly.

The Science of Second Chances

Here’s why this works as part of our email marketing strategy: Different strokes for different folks. Some folks are morning people; some are night owls. Some check their emails religiously on weekdays; others play catch-up over the weekend. You’re giving your email the second chance it deserves by playing around with the timing and adding a slight twist to the subject line (because nobody likes a repeat).

Audience Segmentation: The Hidden Layer

The critical layer of audience segmentation lies beneath the surface of timing and content tweaks. Not everyone on your list ignored your first email for the same reason. Some might have been busy; others might find a different subject line more appealing.

You can tailor your resend email marketing strategy to match their preferences and habits by analysing engagement patterns and segmenting your audience based on behaviour. This means not just changing when you send your email, but possibly also whom you’re sending it to.

To Resend or Not to Resend?

Now, you might be wondering, “Phil, can we resend again?” Hold your horses. While a third resend might be tempting, there’s a better play.

Bonus Tactic! Enter the Re-engagement Email.

This beauty is all about cleaning up your list. It’s simple: those who engage, stay. Those who don’t, well, it might be time to part ways. It’s like tidying up your Lego box – keeping the pieces that fit and saying goodbye to the ones that don’t.

Send the re-engagement email, give the openers the direct call to action to UNSUBSCRIBE, and yes remove themselves, if they don’t, they stay in, and then the non-openers, get removed from future campaigns.

Net result: Improving your deliverability, engagement, and your overall list health.

The Psychological Play

A resend, especially when done purposefully, taps into the fear of missing out (FOMO). It signals to your audience that you’re offering something valuable—so valuable that you’re giving them a second chance not to miss it. This psychological play can be particularly effective when coupled with a compelling call to action or a time-sensitive offer.

The Bigger Picture: Building Relationships

Ultimately, the strategy behind the resend goes beyond open rates and click-throughs—it’s about building and maintaining relationships with your audience. By showing that you understand their habits and respect their time, you’re not just selling; you’re engaging in a conversation.

Fin! For now… on Email Marketing Strategy

If you’re not seeing the open rates you’re dreaming of, don’t despair. Sometimes, all it takes is a little nudge, a tweak in timing, or a fresh subject line to catch your audience’s attention. And if you’re still stuck, give me or the team a shout. We’re here to help you nail this tactic and watch your metrics climb.

Remember, in the world of email marketing, it’s the little tweaks that lead to big peaks. Keep building, keep testing, and most importantly, keep resending (wisely, of course).

Until next time, keep those emails flying and those inboxes buzzing!

Like this article? Share it with somebody!

Facebook
Linkedin
Twitter
Skype
Telegram
Email